DJB Holding Corp. v. Commissioner

by
WCI was owned by WB Acquisition, which was owned by WBPartners, which in turn was owned by Daren Barone’s and Gregory Watkins’s holding corporations. WCI and WB Partners formed a joint venture called the NTC Joint Venture. The joint venture’s structure had significant federal income tax consequences. While the NTC project was ongoing, WCI sold its assets to Kuranda. WB Partners, WB Acquisition, and Barone's holding corporation (collectively, Taxpayers) challenged certain tax deficiencies identified by the Commissioner. In three consolidated decisions, the Tax Court found that the NTC Joint Venture was not a valid partnership for tax purposes, and therefore that all of the joint venture’s profits were taxable income to WCI. The Tax Court determined that all of the proceeds from the noncompetition agreement were income to WCI as well. Because WCI had substantially understated its income, the Tax Court upheld the Commissioner’s assessment of accuracy-related penalties. The court concluded that income from the NTC Project attributed to WB Partners was in fact income to WCL; proceeds from the noncompetition agreement were income to WCI rather than WB Partners; and the Tax Court properly assessed accuracy-related penalties. Accordingly, the court affirmed the judgment. View "DJB Holding Corp. v. Commissioner" on Justia Law