Justia U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in Criminal Law
USA V. GRANDY
Victor Grandy was convicted by a jury in 1993 for distributing at least fifty grams of crack cocaine, violating 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)(1). He was sentenced to life imprisonment and a ten-year term of supervised release, as required by the statute at the time. After serving over twenty-six years in prison, Grandy’s sentence was reduced in 2019 under the First Step Act, and he began his supervised release. During supervised release, Grandy demonstrated successful reintegration, maintaining stable employment, volunteering, and pursuing a flourishing art career. However, the conditions of supervised release limited his ability to travel for art shows. In February 2025, Grandy moved for early termination of supervised release, citing his exemplary conduct and professional burdens.The United States District Court for the Central District of California denied Grandy’s motion. The court reasoned that the mandatory minimum term of supervised release imposed under 21 U.S.C. § 841(b)(1) precluded early termination. It further determined Grandy had not shown extraordinary circumstances warranting early termination, relying on extrarecord sources: a 2022 U.S. Sentencing Commission recidivism study and an outdated Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts’ Guide. The court misinterpreted statistics from the study and applied an obsolete nine-factor test, concluding Grandy’s ongoing success justified continued supervision.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed the case. It held that 21 U.S.C. § 841(b)(1) does not prohibit early termination of supervised release under 18 U.S.C. § 3583(e)(1), as the government conceded. The Ninth Circuit found the district court abused its discretion by misinterpreting extrarecord evidence, relying on outdated guidance, and treating Grandy’s success as a reason for continued supervision. The court reversed the denial of Grandy’s motion and remanded for further proceedings, declining to reassign the case to a different judge. View "USA V. GRANDY" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
USA V. RIDLEY-THOMAS
A former member of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors was convicted for conspiracy, federal program bribery, and honest services mail and wire fraud. The case centered on a scheme where the then-Dean of the University of Southern California’s School of Social Work helped channel a $100,000 donation of university funds to a nonprofit employing the supervisor’s son. In exchange, the supervisor voted in favor of a county contract for telehealth services with USC. The evidence showed the supervisor valued the indirect transfer of funds for his son’s benefit, especially after previous attempts to provide direct funding raised concerns about nepotism.The United States District Court for the Central District of California presided over a sixteen-day trial. The jury convicted the supervisor on counts specifically related to the funneling of the $100,000 payment, while acquitting him on other counts tied to his son’s admission, scholarship, or professorship at USC. Following conviction, the supervisor appealed, challenging the Government’s theory of fraud and bribery, the legal validity of the “thing of value,” and the sufficiency of evidence for materiality and intent. He also contested the jury instructions and raised Batson challenges regarding the exclusion of Black female jurors.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed the appeal. The court held that the funneling of $100,000 through USC for the son’s benefit was a “thing of value” sufficient to support convictions for honest services fraud and federal program bribery. The court found the evidence of intent and materiality sufficient, determined there was no error in the jury instructions, and rejected the extension of Batson to intersectional challenges. The convictions for conspiracy, federal program bribery, and honest services fraud were affirmed. View "USA V. RIDLEY-THOMAS" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law, White Collar Crime
USA V. ABDUL KAREEM
The defendant was accused of participating in a plan to attack a public event in Garland, Texas, which was targeted for its association with controversial depictions of the Prophet Muhammad. The attack was carried out by two individuals, Simpson and Soofi, who were killed during the incident. Investigators uncovered evidence of the defendant’s close association with the attackers, his consumption of extremist propaganda, and his involvement in firearms training and procurement. The government argued that the defendant, along with Simpson and Soofi, conspired to provide material support to ISIS, specifically as “personnel” or by providing “services” in the form of the attack.After a trial in the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, a jury convicted the defendant on all counts, including conspiracy to provide material support to a foreign terrorist organization in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2339B (Count 5). The district court sentenced him to 360 months’ imprisonment. Post-trial, the defendant filed motions for acquittal and new trials, including arguments based on Brady violations, but relief was denied for Count 5. The government dismissed another count, and the district court resentenced him to the same term. The defendant timely appealed his conviction on Count 5, arguing insufficient evidence to support the jury’s finding.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed the sufficiency of the evidence under the Jackson v. Virginia standard, regardless of whether the claim was preserved below. The court held that the government failed to present sufficient evidence that the defendant intended to join a conspiracy in which material support would be provided to ISIS, either as “personnel” acting under ISIS’s direction or as “services” beyond independent advocacy. The court reversed the conviction on Count 5, remanded for entry of acquittal and resentencing, and affirmed the district court’s rulings on all other issues. View "USA V. ABDUL KAREEM" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
USA V. MUMMA
A defendant was investigated after a private investigator discovered a memory card containing surreptitious recordings of his stepdaughter undressing in her bedroom. Law enforcement executed a search warrant at the defendant’s home, uncovering a hidden camera disguised as a charger in the victim’s room and multiple explicit videos and images of the minor, recorded over a period of several years. The defendant had organized these materials and stored them in a concealed media vault on his phone.The defendant was indicted in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California for sexual exploitation of a minor under 18 U.S.C. § 2251(a). He moved to dismiss the indictment, arguing it was insufficiently specific and did not provide adequate notice of the charges. The district court denied the motion, finding the indictment adequately alleged the essential elements. After a jury trial resulted in a guilty verdict, the district court imposed a 252-month sentence, ordered restitution to the victim, and entered a personal forfeiture money judgment representing the proceeds from the sale of the defendant’s house, where the offense occurred.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed three main issues. First, it affirmed the district court’s denial of the motion to dismiss, holding that the indictment sufficiently tracked the statutory language and included all necessary elements. Second, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the forfeiture order, concluding that even if the district court erred by not inquiring whether the jury should determine forfeitability, any error was harmless because the use of the house to commit the offense was uncontested and indisputable. Third, the Ninth Circuit vacated the restitution order due to a mathematical error and remanded for recalculation and clarification regarding certain housing expenses. The judgment was affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded. View "USA V. MUMMA" on Justia Law
USA V. ANDERSON
The defendant was indicted for possession with intent to distribute methamphetamine and fentanyl, unlawful possession of a firearm, and possession of a firearm in furtherance of a drug trafficking crime. After his motion to suppress evidence was denied, he pleaded guilty to possession with intent to distribute. As part of his plea agreement, he waived his right to appeal his conviction and sentence, and both he and his trial counsel affirmed that he had been advised of the agreement’s contents. Six months after sentencing, he filed a pro se motion under 28 U.S.C. § 2255, alleging ineffective assistance of counsel because his trial lawyer failed to file an appeal despite being directed to do so.The United States District Court for the District of Idaho ordered the government to respond and requested a declaration from the defendant’s trial counsel, who denied that the defendant asked him to file an appeal. The district court denied the § 2255 motion without holding an evidentiary hearing, concluding that the defendant merely “discussed” his desire to appeal after sentencing but did not directly instruct his counsel to file an appeal. The court also found that trial counsel’s affidavit contradicted any claim that the defendant had given such instructions, and determined that a hearing would be futile since the defendant had knowingly waived his appeal rights.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed the district court’s decision. The panel held that the defendant’s pro se allegations, when liberally construed, sufficiently claimed ineffective assistance by asserting he directed counsel to appeal. The Ninth Circuit determined that the district court abused its discretion by resolving the credibility dispute between conflicting sworn statements without an evidentiary hearing. The panel vacated the district court’s order denying relief and remanded for an evidentiary hearing to assess the credibility of both the defendant and his trial counsel. View "USA V. ANDERSON" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
USA V. LE
Three individuals departed from Dana Point Harbor in Southern California at night, ostensibly for a lobster-fishing trip. When the boat returned, one person was missing, and his body was later found floating in the ocean with evidence of drowning, gunshot wounds, and blunt force trauma. Location data placed the incident within three nautical miles of the California coast. The surviving participants did not report the death. Following an investigation, federal authorities charged one of the surviving individuals with first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and possession of a firearm in furtherance of murder.The United States District Court for the Central District of California heard the case. The defense argued that the federal government lacked jurisdiction because the death occurred within the three-nautical-mile territorial sea, which they claimed was under California's exclusive criminal jurisdiction. The district court rejected this argument, finding that federal jurisdiction extended twelve nautical miles from shore under the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996. At trial, the jury was instructed accordingly and convicted the defendant on all counts. During jury deliberations, a juror experiencing distress and mental health concerns, which were linked to pressure from other jurors regarding the verdict, was excused and replaced by an alternate, with the agreement of both parties. The reconstituted jury returned guilty verdicts.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that the federal government’s jurisdiction under Title 18 did extend to the first three nautical miles from shore. However, the appellate court found that the removal of the juror violated the defendant’s Sixth Amendment right to a unanimous jury verdict because her dismissal stemmed from her views on the merits of the case. The Ninth Circuit vacated the convictions and remanded the case for further proceedings. View "USA V. LE" on Justia Law
USA V. YOUNGBLOOD
Dylan Youngblood was arrested in Kalispell, Montana, in September 2023 on an outstanding felony warrant. During the arrest, officers found fentanyl pills on his person and located two pistols, drug paraphernalia, and suspected methamphetamine in his car. Youngblood admitted ownership of one pistol and to having used fentanyl earlier that day. He was indicted for possessing a firearm while being an unlawful user of, and addicted to, a controlled substance, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(3).In the United States District Court for the District of Montana, Youngblood moved to dismiss the indictment, arguing that § 922(g)(3) was unconstitutional both on its face and as applied to him. The district court denied the motion, applying the Second Amendment framework from New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n v. Bruen, and found that while Youngblood’s conduct fell within the Second Amendment’s text, the statute’s application to frequent users of methamphetamine and fentanyl was consistent with a historical tradition of temporarily disarming intoxicated individuals. The district court concluded that the statute was both facially and as-applied constitutional. Youngblood then entered a conditional guilty plea, preserving his right to appeal the denial of his motion.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed the case. The court held that its prior decision in United States v. Stennerson, which upheld the facial constitutionality of § 922(g)(3), remained binding even after the Supreme Court’s decision in United States v. Hemani, which addressed only an as-applied challenge. The Ninth Circuit also found that Youngblood waived his as-applied challenge by failing to argue it specifically and distinctly in his opening brief. The court affirmed Youngblood’s conviction. View "USA V. YOUNGBLOOD" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Criminal Law
USA V. SO
Federal officials learned in December 2015 about a scheme to launder $5 million from South Korea to the United States for the purpose of bribing General Motors executives. The aim was for Woo Kyung M.I.T., a South Korean automotive supplier, to secure a lucrative GM contract. After a first payment, further funds were transferred through hawala brokers. Following an airport search, the bribe was delivered to Hyoung Nam “Brian” So. Shortly after, Woo Kyung M.I.T. was awarded the GM contract, but later withdrew due to profitability concerns and the ongoing investigation. Most of the bribe money was eventually returned, and South Korean officials arrested Lee, who pleaded guilty and cooperated with U.S. authorities.A formal request for evidence under the Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT) was made to South Korea in July 2017, seeking documents and certifications relevant to the investigation. Several responses followed, with South Korean officials continuing efforts to provide requested certifications until October 2021. In September 2020, the government sought to toll the statute of limitations under 18 U.S.C. § 3292, citing ongoing requests for evidence. The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California issued a tolling order, suspending the statute of limitations for offenses described in the government’s application. On March 23, 2022, So was indicted for conspiracy to commit federal funds bribery. So moved to dismiss the indictment as untimely, but the district court found the offense covered by the tolling order and denied the motion. The court also refused to instruct the jury on the statute-of-limitations issue, ruling it was a question for the judge.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that the tolling order applied to conspiracy to commit federal funds bribery, even though the offense was not specifically cited by statute. The panel concluded the indictment was timely, as final action by South Korean authorities occurred after the natural limitations period. The court also held that the district court properly resolved the statute-of-limitations issue without submitting it to the jury. The conviction and district court decisions were affirmed. View "USA V. SO" on Justia Law
CASTILLO V. BEAN
The case involves William Castillo, who was convicted and sentenced to death for the murder of Isabelle Berndt in Las Vegas, Nevada. Castillo used a key he found while working as a roofer at Berndt’s home to later enter her residence with an accomplice, steal items, and fatally attack Berndt with a tire iron. Subsequently, he returned to the home to set it on fire. Evidence recovered from Castillo’s apartment linked him to the crime. He confessed to the robbery, murder, and arson during police interrogation and was convicted by a jury on multiple counts, including first-degree murder. The penalty phase included testimony regarding his abusive childhood and mental health, but the jury imposed a death sentence.After his conviction, Castillo appealed to the Nevada Supreme Court, which affirmed both the conviction and sentence. His state post-conviction relief (PCR) petition was denied by the trial court and affirmed by the Nevada Supreme Court. Castillo then filed a federal habeas corpus petition in the United States District Court for the District of Nevada. He voluntarily dismissed the petition, but later moved to reopen it. His subsequent amended petitions were dismissed by the district court as untimely or procedurally defaulted. The district court granted a certificate of appealability for four claims and denied it for two others.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reviewed the case. It held that Castillo’s first and second amended habeas petitions were untimely and equitable tolling was not warranted. The court affirmed denial of relief on most claims, including ineffective assistance of trial counsel and the as-applied Eighth Amendment challenge to Nevada’s lethal injection protocol. However, the court reversed the district court’s ruling on two claims, finding that attorney error in state PCR proceedings could excuse procedural default under Martinez v. Ryan and Hogan v. Bean. Those claims were remanded for further proceedings. The court affirmed denial of certificates of appealability for the remaining claims. View "CASTILLO V. BEAN" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Criminal Law
LING V. CITY OF LOS ANGELES
The City of Los Angeles received millions in federal housing grants over a period of years, certifying compliance with federal housing accessibility laws as a condition of those funds. Mei Ling and the Fair Housing Council of the San Fernando Valley (FHC) brought a qui tam action under the False Claims Act (FCA), alleging that the City had falsely represented its compliance with accessibility requirements. The United States later intervened in the case. Separately, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) investigated the City for noncompliance and, after its own findings, entered into a Voluntary Compliance Agreement (VCA) with the City. Under the VCA, the City agreed to spend at least $200 million over ten years to remediate or build accessible housing, but the VCA explicitly excluded the FCA claims at issue in the litigation.The United States District Court for the Central District of California presided over years of discovery and litigation. Eventually, the United States, FHC, and the City agreed to settle the FCA claims for $38,266,989. The district court approved the settlement as fair, adequate, and reasonable, and dismissed all claims against the City, with relators entitled to a statutory share of the settlement proceeds. Mei Ling appealed, arguing that the VCA constituted an “alternate remedy” under the FCA, which would entitle her to a share of the VCA’s value.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that the VCA was not an alternate remedy within the meaning of 31 U.S.C. § 3730(c)(5) because it did not take the place of the FCA suit or settlement. The VCA addressed the City’s civil rights violations, not the alleged fraud underlying the FCA action, and expressly carved out the FCA claims. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s approval of the FCA settlement. View "LING V. CITY OF LOS ANGELES" on Justia Law